Monday, July 16, 2007

Debate

He was coming home after a heated debate. This was his routine. He would debate anywhere on anything. It can be at the book shop about — How Shakespeare’s work is simply scribbling of a mind gone worse or at the tea-stall about — how the decrease in sugar production may lead to people drinking sugarless tea. It appeared that everything was debatable for him. Often behind his back people would comment that he can also debate the reason of his birth— was it a pleasurable act or were his parents having sex to raise a family!
Whatever, people loved to see him debating. Unlike others, he always backed his arguments with facts and figures. There were doubts that he conjure them up. But this got cleared when once a so called educationalist verified that his figure on the number of known religions in the world was accurate. Well, nothing much changed from this revelation, except that the cigarette-shop owner nearby started referring to him as ‘neta ji’ (leader).
For they never took those debates seriously. What excited them was his passion. So, the question of right facts and figures didn’t bother them. They always wanted to see someone new, who didn’t know about his reputation,to debate with him. To their astonishment, he never got angry or shouted or to the disappointment of many had a street-fight. He simply debated.

There were theories about— who he was? Where he came from? What he does? According to most, they knew it all but just can’t simply recall. Whenever asked, he would simply smile and point to anyone and say — didn’t I tell you? That person would become the centre of attraction for many days, as if he knew the secret. There were many who denied it, some who revered in the glory and made-up stories and some who said they can’t break his faith. By the end of the year, there were 100 stories about him or may be more.

But today, he was disappointed. The debate was a soul-searching one. Though he had won hands down, he knew that he had lost. He never debated so as to win. But to lose is tougher than winning. He committed suicide that night. No one was aware why he did that. They debated upon it……..

Note: This story reflects my current state of mind (SoM). We both (my SoM and the story) are unaware where to head for...perhaps an abrupt end will justify the justifiable. In my dreams whenever I visit my past I wonder, why I've been so unsuccessful. I can't justify my intiatives, attempts but then maybeI did it all because I've to be unsucessful.......

5 comments:

Sh'shank said...

But D possibly it is because you ahve to find what it is being unsuccessful rather than end it all and not know what it is to be an entire life time of unsuccessful...
From one to another unsuccessful existence... Why not stick around and see the end of the track may be we just might end up being unsuccessfully enlightened.
What say?
----
to answer what you asked on my blog... quite a bit of it is drawn from you know who...

txandi prost said...

always so taken by alegories of the mundane. with subconscious sparked, emotions assault the reader from the pages so much more vividly than if written in technicolor reality. ~t~

Id it is said...

Your posts are always a challenge...

Debating is an age old tradition dating back to Pkato and the sophists, but your debat'er' is unique in that he debates without an objective to win his argument...very interesting!

"Though he had won hands down, he knew that he had lost. He never debated so as to win" - Isn't there an incosistency in that argument?

As for Rowling, believe it or not I've not read any of hers. I tried reading the very first one but didn't get very far.

Also, I'm curious about these 'intellectual masses' you refer to. Love to know more about them, hehe

Cinephile said...

this one is good, well liked it

D said...

I don't knw Pricky..smtimes I feel that all my energy is sapped away on this wild goose chase of the ever eluding success.

Thx Txandi.

III...the whole story was tht this guy was not debating so as to prove a point or win, which kind of defeated the whole process of debating and tht's where he tried to find fun. The day he lost, he didn't lost the debate...he lost smthing more precious and this is wht those who debated with still debating about...

Thx RRabout